DVR (Differential Voting Rights) Shares are equity positions that offer an alternative to owning common shares by providing different voting rights.
DVR shares help companies raise funds without giving up control, as voting rights and financial ownership are divided across different classes of shares.
In general, DVRs may be issued with lower voting rights than regular shares (common stocks) but may offer different dividend entitlements than regular shares. The unique structure of DVRs allows a corporation to raise funds while minimising the dilution of its decision-making authority.
What are DVR Shares?
DVR shares, or Differential Voting Rights shares, represent equity in a company. An individual holds ownership as a shareholder but gets different voting rights than common equity shares.
DVR shares typically carry fewer voting rights than common shares. To balance this decreased control, companies often offer higher dividend structures or other benefits to attract investors.
Using DVR shares lets companies raise capital without a significant dilution of control for promoters. This helps founders retain strong decision-making influence while receiving outside growth funding.
Why Do Companies Create DVR Shares?
Companies issue DVR shares to raise funds while maintaining corporate control. Issuing different share classes provides capital growth without shifting the internal management structure or business direction.
DVR shares support stability in company control by ensuring that leadership transitions occur slowly. Reducing voting rights prevents dramatic shifts in control caused by short-term stock price fluctuations.
Companies also create DVR shares to attract passive investors. These individuals prefer higher returns and dividend rates over having any direct influence or control over company leadership.
Advantages of DVR Shares
Some of the striking benefits of investing in differential voting rights are as follows:
DVR shares are generally cheaper than regular shares because of diminished voting power, so investors can buy more shares for the same investment.
To offset less voting power, DVR shares tend to yield higher dividends. For example, Tata Motors DVR shares give a 5% greater dividend than its regular shares.
Investors are more interested in returns than in corporate governance, like DVR shares, as they can profit financially without participating in company decisions.
Issuing DVR shares allows companies to raise capital while enabling promoters to retain decision-making powers, as these shares have limited voting rights.
With limited voting rights, DVR shares make it more difficult for outside parties to take control, thereby safeguarding the company from hostile takeover attempts.
With increased dividends and lower stock prices, DVR shares entice retail investors looking for stable returns, thus expanding the base of the investor.
Limitations of DVR Shares
The share market has its limitations, irrespective of the types of shares. In the case of DVR shares also, there are certain limitations. These are:
Limited Voting Power and Less Influence
DVR shareholders enjoy far fewer voting rights than normal shareholders. For example, in Tata Motors, DVR shares hold one vote for ten held, while ordinary shares hold one vote per unit. This restriction prohibits investors from making decisions on behalf of the company.
Some of the regulatory constraints may be:
Indian companies are prohibited from issuing DVR shares beyond 26% of the total post-issue paid-up equity share capital. The cap restricts the degree to which companies can use DVR shares for fundraising.
For issuing DVR shares, certain conditions have to be met by companies, like having distributable profits for the last three years and not having defaulted in filing the annual accounts or repayment of deposits or interest:\ These are strict requirements that may be difficult for certain companies to comply with.
Market Perception and Liquidity
The following are the effects on liquidity:
Since DVR shares have limited voting rights, they tend to be traded at a discount relative to their ordinary counterparts. Discounted valuation may reflect on the market capitalization of the company and may not necessarily capture the intrinsic value of the shares.
DVR shares are normally subject to lower trading volume, resulting in lesser liquidity. This can further hinder investors to sell or purchase huge volumes without affecting the share price
Institutional investors normally look for strong influence within the governance of firms. The diluted voting rights pertaining to DVR shares can restrict such investors from getting attracted to it, limiting the investor group.
Difference Between DVR Shares and Ordinary Shares
Basis
| DVR Shares
| Ordinary Shares
|
Voting Rights
| Fewer votes per share (e.g., one vote per 10 shares)
| One vote per share
|
Dividends
| May differ from ordinary shares
| Depends on performance
|
Control
| Limited influence
| Full influence
|
Issue Purpose
| Retain control
| Share control
|
Market Price
| Often trades at a discount
| Usually higher
|
Investor Type
| Income-focused
| Control-focused
|
Example of DVR Shares
Historically, Tata Motors offered a prominent example of DVR shares in India back in 2008, issuing shares with lower voting rights and higher dividend eligibility.
This issuance allowed Tata Motors to broaden its capital base while protecting promoter interests. Investors enjoyed steady dividend income while the company pursued long-term growth plans.
Eligibility Criteria to Issue DVR Shares
- The company’s Articles of Association must explicitly authorise the issuance of shares carrying differential voting rights before any such shares can be issued.
- The firm should have distributable profits for the past three years and no defaults in filing annual returns in that period.
- There should be no defaults in paying deposits, loans, or declared dividends, and no material penalties or convictions.
- DVR shares issued must not exceed 26% of the post-issue paid-up equity capital of the company.
SEBI and Issuance of DVRs
Promoters or founders who occupy executive positions are the only ones who can be granted SR shares.
Net worth of the promoter group cannot be more than ₹500 crore, apart from their investment within the company.
SR shares should be retained for a period of at least six months before the submission of the red herring prospectus for an IPO.
Voting Rights and Issuance Limits
SR shares can carry voting rights between 2:1 and up to 10:1 against ordinary shares.
The aggregate voting rights of the SR shareholders shall not be more than 74% of the aggregate voting power of the company after issue.
Lock-in and Transfer Restrictions
The SR shares are subject to lock-in for the time of conversion into ordinary shares or for a period of three years from the date of IPO, whichever is longer.
Inter-se transfer between promoters and pledging of SR shares are not allowed during the lock-in period.
SR shares get converted to ordinary shares after five years from the listing date.
This can be extended for another five years through a shareholders' resolution but not with the right to vote for SR shareholders.
Improved Corporate Governance
Firms that issue SR shares should have at least 50% independent directors on their board.
Audit committees should be made up entirely of independent directors to ensure transparency and accountability.
SEBI's framework allows companies, especially technology companies, to raise capital from the capital markets while retaining promoter control, subject to strict governance standards and investor protection mechanisms.
Why Should You Invest in DVR Shares?
Now that you know the meaning and purpose of DVR shares, what are your plans? Are you willing to be a part of DVR investors? Well, there are a few things to consider to be able to understand if or not you should invest in DVR shares:
DVR shares tend to pay greater dividends than common shares, offsetting their lower voting rights.
Owing to lesser voting rights, DVR shares usually trade at a discount, enabling investors to purchase shares at a lower price.
Ideal for Passive Investors
DVR stocks are appropriate for those who wish not to become involved in decision-making by a company but desire profits instead.
Coupling of greater dividends with lesser buying costs may result in better return on investment in the long run.
Including DVR stocks within an investment portfolio may diversify, smoothing out risk and reward profiles.
In short, DVR shares offer a lucrative investment option for those who want to earn more dividends and less entry fees, without the need to engage in corporate control. Nevertheless, it's needed to evaluate one's own financial objectives and tolerance of risk prior to investing.