BAJAJ BROKING
July 14, 2025
4 mins read
When investing in mutual funds for periodic income, investors can choose between SWP VS dividend plans. Both options provide regular cash flow but differ in flexibility, taxation, and predictability. Understanding their distinctions is crucial for making an informed investment decision.
A systematic withdrawal plan (SWP) allows investors to withdraw a fixed amount at regular intervals, ensuring a steady and predictable income stream. Investors can choose the withdrawal frequency and amount, making it a customizable option. On the other hand, dividend plans provide income in the form of dividends, which are declared at the discretion of the mutual fund’s asset management company (AMC). The payout amounts and frequency depend on the scheme’s performance, making it unpredictable.
Another key difference lies in taxation. SWP withdrawals are subject to capital gains tax, which depends on the investment's holding period and the type of mutual fund. Meanwhile, dividends are taxed as per the investor’s income tax slab, potentially increasing the overall tax liability. Due to these factors, SWPs are often preferred by those seeking a reliable income source, while dividend plans are suited for investors comfortable with variable payouts.
A systematic withdrawal plan (SWP) is a facility offered by mutual funds that allows investors to withdraw a predetermined amount at fixed intervals. This enables investors to generate a regular income stream while staying invested in the mutual fund. SWP is a structured way to redeem mutual fund units over time, making it a useful strategy for retirees or those needing predictable cash flows.
One of the biggest advantages of SWP is its flexibility. Investors can select the withdrawal amount and frequency—monthly, quarterly, or yearly—based on their financial requirements. Since the units are systematically redeemed, the investment remains partially intact, and the remaining units continue to grow based on market performance.
Another major benefit of SWP is tax efficiency. Withdrawals are taxed as capital gains rather than regular income. Short-term capital gains tax applies if units are withdrawn before a specific holding period, while long-term capital gains tax applies beyond that period. Unlike dividend plans, SWPs do not attract TDS (tax deducted at source), making them a preferred choice for many investors.
A dividend plan is a mutual fund option where investors receive periodic dividend payouts from the scheme’s profits. These payouts are made at the discretion of the fund’s asset management company (AMC) and depend on the fund’s performance and surplus earnings. Investors opting for dividend plans receive these earnings in the form of direct payouts rather than reinvesting them back into the fund.
One of the key aspects of dividend plans is uncertainty in income. Since dividends are not guaranteed and depend on the AMC’s decision, investors may experience fluctuating payouts. Additionally, dividends are taxed as per the investor’s income tax slab, which may lead to a higher tax burden compared to capital gains taxation under SWP. This makes dividend plans more suitable for investors who do not rely on consistent cash flow.
Dividend vs SWP plans both provide regular income from mutual fund investments, but they function differently. While SWP allows investors to withdraw a fixed amount at chosen intervals, dividend payouts depend on the fund’s performance and the asset management company's discretion. This makes SWP a more predictable source of income, whereas dividend payouts may vary.
SWP withdrawals involve redeeming units, which can lead to capital erosion over time if the withdrawal rate exceeds the fund’s returns. Since investors continue to withdraw a fixed sum, their investment value may decline, especially during market downturns. Dividend plans, however, distribute earnings without reducing the number of units held. While dividend payouts lower the NAV, the capital remains intact, making it a more stable option in certain scenarios.
SWP provides investors with control over the frequency of their withdrawals. Investors can choose to withdraw monthly, quarterly, or yearly, depending on their financial needs. This regular payout structure makes it easier for retirees and others relying on a steady cash flow. Dividend payouts, on the other hand, are irregular. Since the AMC decides when to distribute dividends, investors cannot predict the exact frequency, leading to potential financial uncertainty.
SWP is most suitable for investors who require a consistent and structured income stream, such as retirees or individuals seeking regular cash flow. It is particularly useful for those who want to plan their expenses efficiently. Dividend plans may be suitable for investors who do not need fixed payouts and are comfortable with variable earnings. Since dividend payouts depend on fund performance, investors looking for guaranteed income may find SWP a more reliable option.
SWP allows investors to continue benefiting from market growth as the remaining investment stays invested. If the fund performs well, investors may still see portfolio appreciation even after making withdrawals. In dividend plans, payouts reduce the NAV, which affects the compounding potential of the investment. Investors choosing SWP have greater control over their returns, whereas dividend plan investors are subject to AMC decisions, which can impact long-term wealth creation.
Taxation is a significant differentiator between dividend vs SWP plans. SWP withdrawals are considered capital gains and are taxed accordingly. If the withdrawal occurs within a short holding period, short-term capital gains tax applies. Otherwise, long-term capital gains tax is levied, which is generally lower. In contrast, dividends are taxed as per the investor’s income tax slab, which can be higher depending on the tax bracket. This makes SWP a more tax-efficient option for many investors.
SWP is not a separate mutual fund scheme but a withdrawal strategy that investors can apply to any fund. This flexibility allows investors to choose a fund that aligns with their financial goals while managing withdrawals as needed. Dividend plans, however, are specific schemes where investors receive dividends whenever declared by the AMC. The lack of control over payouts makes dividend plans less predictable compared to SWP.
One of the key advantages of SWP is that it promotes disciplined financial management. Since withdrawals are planned and systematic, investors can manage their expenses without making impulsive redemption decisions. Dividend plans, on the other hand, do not offer the same level of financial discipline, as payouts depend on external factors such as fund performance. This unpredictability can make budgeting difficult for those relying on steady income.
Both SWP and dividend plans result in a reduction in NAV, but the mechanisms differ. In SWP, NAV reduces as units are redeemed to generate cash flow, decreasing the total number of units over time. In dividend plans, NAV drops after each dividend payout, but the number of units remains the same. This NAV reduction impacts future returns in both cases, though in SWP, investors have more control over their withdrawal strategy.
Investors can stop an SWP at any time by simply halting withdrawals, which allows their remaining capital to stay invested. This flexibility makes SWP a preferred option for those who may want to pause or modify their withdrawals. In dividend plans, investors cannot control the payouts, as dividends are declared by the AMC. To discontinue dividend income, investors must switch to a growth plan or another scheme.
SWP offers investors the ability to customize withdrawal amounts, allowing them to adjust payouts based on their financial needs. This flexibility helps in managing cash flow efficiently, especially during financial emergencies. Dividend plans, however, do not offer such flexibility. Investors must accept the dividends as declared by the AMC, with no option to modify payout amounts. This makes SWP a more adaptable investment strategy.
SWP ensures that investors receive a fixed and predictable cash flow, making it easier to plan expenses and maintain financial stability. This level of predictability is beneficial for those who depend on investment withdrawals for their livelihood. Dividend plans, however, do not provide this consistency, as payouts depend on fund profitability and AMC discretion. Investors who require a steady income stream may find SWP a more reliable choice.
The table below outlines the key differences between a systematic withdrawal plan (SWP) and a dividend plan, helping investors understand which option aligns better with their financial goals. While SWP offers structured and predictable withdrawals, dividend plans depend on the fund’s performance, leading to variable payouts.
Aspects | SWP | Dividend |
Returns | Investors can withdraw a fixed amount at regular intervals. | The payout amount depends on the mutual fund’s performance and is not guaranteed. |
Suitability | Best suited for retirees and investors seeking a fixed, predictable income. | Suitable for investors comfortable with uncertain but periodic income. |
Capital Erosion | Yes, withdrawals may reduce the initial investment over time. | No, the capital remains intact as dividends are distributed from fund profits. |
Reduction in NAV | The NAV remains unaffected by withdrawals. | The NAV reduces after dividend payouts. |
Type of Scheme | Often linked to low-risk funds like liquid funds. | Investors can choose any fund based on their risk appetite. |
Frequency | Investors can decide withdrawal frequency—monthly, quarterly, or annually. | Dividend payments are determined by the fund house and may be irregular. |
Stopping the Option | Withdrawals can be stopped anytime without affecting the investment. | To stop dividends, investors must exit or switch to a different plan. |
Disciplined Withdrawal | Encourages structured withdrawals for planned financial management. | Leads to an irregular cash flow, making financial planning less predictable. |
This comparison highlights that SWP is a better option for investors seeking consistency and control over their withdrawals, while dividend plans may be suitable for those who do not rely on regular payouts. Understanding these differences can help investors make an informed decision based on their cash flow needs and risk tolerance.
The table below outlines the advantages and disadvantages of a systematic withdrawal plan (SWP), helping investors evaluate whether it aligns with their financial strategy.
Pros | Cons |
Provides a predictable and fixed income stream, helping with financial planning. | Withdrawals reduce the initial investment over time, leading to capital erosion. |
Offers flexibility to choose the withdrawal amount and frequency. | If the fund underperforms, continued withdrawals may deplete the investment faster. |
Tax-efficient as withdrawals are treated as capital gains instead of income. | May not be suitable for investors seeking high-growth investments, as withdrawals limit compounding. |
Investors retain control and can stop or modify withdrawals anytime. | Requires careful planning to ensure withdrawals do not exhaust the investment prematurely. |
No tax deducted at source (TDS) on withdrawals. | Long-term sustainability depends on market performance and investment choice. |
Dividend plans have their own set of benefits and limitations, as highlighted in the table below.
Pros | Cons |
Offers periodic income without reducing the number of units held. | Payouts are unpredictable as they depend on fund performance and AMC discretion. |
Suitable for investors looking for passive income without redeeming units. | NAV reduces after dividend payouts, affecting future growth potential. |
No capital erosion since the investment remains intact. | Taxation is based on the investor’s income tax slab, potentially leading to higher tax liabilities. |
Helps generate liquidity without requiring systematic redemptions. | Investors have no control over the frequency and amount of dividend payouts. |
Dividends can be reinvested in the fund if desired. | Dividends are not guaranteed, making it unreliable for those seeking consistent cash flow. |
Choosing between SWP and dividend plans depends on an investor’s financial goals, risk appetite, and income needs. While SWP provides a structured income with control over withdrawals, dividend plans offer periodic earnings that fluctuate based on market conditions. Investors should assess their tax implications, liquidity preferences, and reinvestment strategies before deciding.
Risk tolerance is a key factor when selecting between SWP and dividend plans. SWP investors assume the risk of depleting their investment if the withdrawal amount is too high or if the fund underperforms. While SWP ensures consistent payouts, it depends on the sustainability of the investment corpus.
Dividend plans, on the other hand, do not involve systematic withdrawals, making them less prone to capital depletion. However, dividends are uncertain, and payouts can fluctuate depending on the fund’s profitability. Investors who prefer stable and predictable income may find SWP more suitable, while those comfortable with variable returns might opt for dividend plans.
For low-risk investors, SWP is a preferred choice as it provides greater control over cash flow. Meanwhile, investors with a higher risk appetite may opt for dividend plans, understanding that income may vary based on market performance.
Investors with fixed income needs, such as retirees, often prefer SWP since it ensures a predetermined payout at chosen intervals. This structured withdrawal system helps maintain financial stability and covers regular expenses without depending on market fluctuations.
Dividend plans, however, are suitable for investors who do not require steady monthly income but are open to periodic earnings. Since the amount and timing of dividends depend on the fund’s profitability and AMC’s discretion, it is not an ideal option for those needing consistent cash flow.
For investors looking to supplement their income with scheduled withdrawals, SWP is the better option. Dividend plans work better for those comfortable with receiving occasional surplus cash when the fund generates profits.
Taxation plays a crucial role in deciding between SWP and dividend plans. In an SWP, withdrawals are taxed as capital gains, which can be more tax-efficient based on the holding period and fund type. Short-term capital gains tax applies if the units are sold before a specific period, whereas long-term capital gains tax applies beyond that period.
Dividend income, however, is taxed based on the investor’s income tax slab, which may result in a higher tax burden for those in higher brackets. Unlike SWP, where the tax can be managed by controlling withdrawals, dividend taxation is fixed and cannot be avoided.
For tax-conscious investors, SWP is often the preferred option as it allows for better tax planning. Dividend plans may not be as tax-efficient, particularly for individuals in higher income brackets.
Investors who want to maximize returns may prefer SWP since any remaining units in the fund continue to compound and grow over time. Even after withdrawals, the balance investment remains invested, helping investors benefit from long-term appreciation.
In dividend plans, payouts reduce the fund’s NAV, which impacts compounding and overall returns. Investors who receive dividends may reinvest them manually, but they do not compound within the fund unless reinvested in a growth plan.
For those aiming for long-term wealth accumulation, SWP may be more suitable since withdrawals are controlled while the remaining investment continues to grow. Dividend plans work better for those who want immediate payouts rather than reinvesting earnings.
Market conditions should be considered when choosing between SWP and dividend plans. SWP is less dependent on market fluctuations since it allows fixed withdrawals regardless of fund performance. However, in prolonged downturns, withdrawals can erode the capital if the fund does not generate sufficient returns to compensate for withdrawals.
Dividend plans depend on fund profitability, meaning payouts may be lower or absent during weak market conditions. When markets are performing well, dividends may be higher, but during volatile phases, income may be inconsistent.
For investors who want an income source unaffected by market conditions, SWP is a better option. Those willing to accept income fluctuations based on fund performance may opt for dividend plans, provided they are comfortable with periods of lower or no payouts.
The decision between SWP VS dividend plan depends on an investor’s financial goals, risk tolerance, and need for regular income. While both options provide periodic cash flow, they operate differently, with SWP offering greater flexibility and control, whereas dividend plans depend on the fund’s performance and the discretion of the asset management company.
SWP is a preferred option for those seeking a predictable and structured withdrawal strategy. Investors can decide how much and when to withdraw, ensuring financial stability. This makes it particularly suitable for retirees or individuals relying on mutual fund investments as a steady income source. Since SWP does not depend on market fluctuations or fund profitability, it provides consistent payouts regardless of external conditions.
Dividend plans, on the other hand, offer payouts based on the fund’s performance. If a fund generates profits, the asset management company distributes dividends to investors. However, these payouts are uncertain and may not always align with an investor’s financial needs. Dividend plans may be more suitable for those who do not rely on fixed monthly income and prefer occasional surplus payouts.
Taxation is another key differentiating factor. SWP withdrawals are taxed as capital gains, which can be more tax-efficient based on the holding period and fund type. Dividends, however, are taxed as income based on the investor’s tax slab, potentially increasing the tax burden for those in higher brackets. Investors in higher tax slabs may find SWP a more effective option for minimizing tax liabilities.
Considering financial security, tax efficiency, and consistency in income, SWP is often regarded as a better choice than dividend plans. It ensures that investors can withdraw a set amount while still benefiting from market appreciation. Dividend plans are better suited for investors willing to accept unpredictable cash flow based on fund performance.
SWP provides a structured and predictable income stream, making it an ideal choice for investors who need financial stability. Unlike dividend plans, where payouts are inconsistent and subject to fund performance, SWP offers fixed withdrawals, allowing better financial planning. Additionally, SWP withdrawals are more tax-efficient, as they are taxed as capital gains rather than ordinary income, making them a superior choice for those in higher tax brackets.
Financial stability is essential for individuals looking to secure their family’s future. SWP helps investors generate a steady cash flow, ensuring that monthly expenses, medical needs, and education costs are covered. Since withdrawals are pre-planned and systematic, families can avoid financial uncertainty that may arise from irregular income sources.
Dividend plans, on the other hand, provide inconsistent payouts, which may not always align with financial obligations. Since dividends depend on fund profitability, they can fluctuate, making them unreliable for families relying on them for regular expenses. For those prioritizing family financial security, SWP remains a more reliable choice than dividend plans.
One of the key advantages of SWP is its tax efficiency. SWP withdrawals are treated as capital gains, which may be more beneficial depending on the holding period and fund type. Investors can optimize their tax liabilities by structuring their withdrawals accordingly, ensuring that they pay minimal taxes while maintaining a stable income.
Dividend plans, however, are taxed as regular income, making them less tax-efficient, especially for high-income individuals. Since dividends are taxed at the investor’s income tax slab, they could lead to a higher tax burden. Investors looking for better post-tax returns often find SWP a more attractive option compared to dividend plans.
SWP offers a structured withdrawal plan that shields investors from market volatility. Regardless of short-term market fluctuations, investors can continue to withdraw a fixed amount at regular intervals. This provides financial consistency, allowing investors to meet their financial needs without worrying about market downturns.
Dividend plans, however, are directly linked to market performance. If markets are down, dividends may not be declared, leaving investors without expected payouts. This unpredictability makes dividend plans less appealing to those who depend on mutual fund income for regular expenses. SWP ensures stability, whereas dividend plans expose investors to market risk.
One of the main reasons investors choose SWP over dividend plans is the assurance of fixed and predictable cash flow. Since withdrawals are pre-determined, investors can plan their finances efficiently without worrying about fluctuations in their income. This makes SWP ideal for retirees and individuals who prefer financial certainty.
Dividend plans, in contrast, offer no guarantee of returns. If the fund does not perform well, dividends may not be distributed, leading to irregular cash flow. For investors seeking reliable returns, SWP remains a more favorable choice than dividend plans.
Both SWP and dividend plans offer ways to generate periodic income, but SWP provides greater predictability, control, and tax efficiency. It ensures that investors receive a structured and reliable payout without being affected by market volatility. The ability to customize withdrawals further enhances its suitability for financial planning.
Investors seeking steady and tax-efficient income should consider SWP, especially for long-term financial stability. Dividend plans may be suitable for those who prefer occasional surplus income but do not rely on fixed payouts. Understanding individual financial goals and taxation implications is essential before making a choice between SWP and dividend plans.
Share this article: 
What is GIFT Nifty?
March 25, 2025 | 6 mins read
Advantages and Disadvantages of Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB) Investment
September 27, 2024 | 9 Min. read
Manufacturing Sector in India
September 27, 2023 | 4 Min. read
Forex Market Hours in India – Know the Best Timings
June 16, 2024 | 6 Min. read
How to Avoid LTCG Tax on Mutual Funds?
December 26, 2024 | 6 Min. read
Gold Price In India Today
May 19, 2025 | 5 Min. read
Why Gold Rate is Increasing?
November 29, 2024 | 3 Min. read
No result found
SWP provides regular income while keeping the investment in mutual funds, whereas fixed deposits offer fixed interest. SWP withdrawals are market-linked, while FD returns are guaranteed.
Investors looking for periodic income without redeeming their units benefit from dividends in mutual funds. However, dividends are irregular and depend on fund performance and asset management company discretion.
SWP is beneficial for investors seeking predictable cash flow while remaining invested in mutual funds. It allows flexibility in withdrawal amounts and may be more tax-efficient than dividend plans.
No, SWP withdrawals are subject to capital gains tax. Short-term and long-term capital gains tax apply based on the holding period and the type of mutual fund.
Yes, SWP allows investors to choose withdrawal frequency, such as monthly, quarterly, or annually, based on financial needs, making it a flexible option compared to dividend plans.
Yes, SWP promotes a disciplined approach to withdrawals, allowing investors to receive periodic cash flow while maintaining the remaining investment for potential market growth.
SWP may lead to capital erosion if withdrawals exceed returns. Market fluctuations can impact the investment value, and improper planning may result in faster depletion of funds.
Yes, dividends received from mutual funds are taxable as per the investor’s income tax slab, making them potentially less tax-efficient compared to SWP withdrawals.
Low-risk funds, such as liquid funds or debt funds, are often preferred for SWP since they offer stability. However, equity funds can also be used depending on the investor’s risk tolerance.
In dividend plans, the asset management company distributes earnings to investors whenever the fund generates surplus profits. However, dividends are not guaranteed and depend on fund performance.
Disclaimer :
The information on this website is provided on "AS IS" basis. Bajaj Broking (BFSL) does not warrant the accuracy of the information given herein, either expressly or impliedly, for any particular purpose and expressly disclaims any warranties of merchantability or suitability for any particular purpose. While BFSL strives to ensure accuracy, it does not guarantee the completeness, reliability, or timeliness of the information. Users are advised to independently verify details and stay updated with any changes.
The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and is subject to change without prior notice. BFSL shall not be responsible for any consequences arising from reliance on the information provided herein and shall not be held responsible for all or any actions that may subsequently result in any loss, damage and or liability. Interest rates, fees, and charges etc., are revised from time to time, for the latest details please refer to our Pricing page.
Neither the information, nor any opinion contained in this website constitutes a solicitation or offer by BFSL or its affiliates to buy or sell any securities, futures, options or other financial instruments or provide any investment advice or service.
BFSL is acting as distributor for non-broking products/ services such as IPO, Mutual Fund, Insurance, PMS, and NPS. These are not Exchange Traded Products. For more details on risk factors, terms and conditions please read the sales brochure carefully before investing.
Investments in the securities market are subject to market risk, read all related documents carefully before investing. This content is for educational purposes only. Securities quoted are exemplary and not recommendatory.
For more disclaimer, check here : https://www.bajajbroking.in/disclaimer
Level up your stock market experience: Download the Bajaj Broking App for effortless investing and trading
Open Your Free Demat Account
Enjoy low brokerage on delivery trades
|
Please Enter Mobile Number
Open Your Free Demat Account
Enjoy low brokerage on delivery trades
|
TRENDING CALCULATORS AND STOCKS ON BAJAJ BROKING
POPULAR STOCKS: Tata Motors Share Price Infosys Share Price IRFC Share Price SBI Card Share Price Cipla Share Price NBCC Share Price IDFC First Bank Share Price IRCTC Share Price PNB Share Price Vodafone Idea Share Price Axis Bank Share Price JSW Steel Share Price Bandhan Bank Share Price SBI Share Price Tata Steel Share Price ONGC Share Price Ashok Leyland Share Price Paytm Share Price Subex Share Price DLF Share Price Reliance Share Price HDFC Bank Share Price Suzlon Share Price IOC Share Price HUL Share Price Asian Paints Share Price Bank Of Baroda Share Price ITC Share Price TCS Share Price HFCL Share Price Icici Bank Share Price Tata Chemicals Share Price CDSI Share Price MRF Share Price Tata Power Share Price Adani Green share price BPCL Share Price Vedanta Share Price Dmart Share Price Hindalco Share Price LIC Share Price SAIL Share Price Adani Port Share Price IEX Share Price Nalco Share Price L&T Share Price Adani Power Share Price BHEL Share Price Bajaj Finance Share Price Canara Bank Share Price Indusind Bank Share Price Gail Share Price Yes Bank Share Price Wipro Share Price Happiest Minds Share Price Coal India Share Price Maruti Share Price Reliance Power Share Price
INDIAN INDICES: Nifty 50 Share Price SENSEX Share Price Nifty Next 50 Share Price BSE100 Share Price Nifty Bank Share Price LRGCAP Share Price Nifty 100 Share Price MIDCAP Share Price Nifty 200 Share Price SMLCAP Share Price Nifty 500 Share Price BSE500 Share Price Nifty Midcap 50 Share Price ALLCAP Share Price NIFTY SMLCAP 50 Share Price BSE200 Share Price India VIX Share Price BSEIPO Share Price
