Contingent Convertible Bonds, or CoCo Bonds, are a unique form of debt that is primarily used by banks and financial institutions. CoCo Bonds differ from traditional bonds in that they can convert into shares of the issuing company under certain conditions.
These instruments first gained popularity after the global financial crisis of 2008, which resulted in significant losses incurred by several banks around the globe. Governments across all jurisdictions were willing to intervene to reduce and ideally eliminate any future financial crises moving forward. The regulatory response was to strengthen banks. One of the measures that was used was to allow banks to continue to exist without having to be bailed out by governments by introducing CoCo Bonds.
What are CoCo Bonds?
CoCo Bonds were first introduced after the financial crisis to help banks meet Basel III rules. Basel III is an international set of banking rules made to make banks more stable and less likely to fail.
These bonds were designed to stop governments from having to use taxpayers’ money to rescue banks. If a bank starts losing too much money or becomes weak, CoCo Bonds can automatically convert into shares. This gives the bank extra capital to stay strong and continue running.
How Do CoCo Bonds Work?
The first CoCo Bonds were issued in 2009, and since then, they have become popular in Europe and Asia. Many large banks use them as part of their capital planning because they help meet legal requirements and provide extra financial safety.
In simple terms, CoCo Bonds are like a safety cushion for banks. When things go wrong, they can change from loans into ownership shares to keep the bank alive.
CoCo Bonds are unique because they are hybrid securities. This means they usually behave like an ordinary bond, but it will convert into shares if a bank experiences difficulties.
Key Features of CoCo Bonds
There are some distinctive characteristics that you should know:
1. Trigger Event
A trigger event is a certain condition leading to the CoCo Bond converting into shares. For example, if the bank's capital goes below a given level (e.g. 7% or 8%), the bond would convert at that point. By doing this, the bond provides more equity to support the bank through the stress event.
2. Conversion Mechanism
When the trigger event happens, the bondholder’s money is changed into shares. Usually, this happens at a discount, meaning investors might get fewer shares than they expect. After the conversion, the investors become part-owners of the bank instead of lenders. This can be risky if the bank’s share price is falling.
3. Temporary Nature
Certain CoCo Bonds do not change directly into shares in the bank; instead, the bonds are written down. This means that part of the money owed to bond investors will be written off to protect the bank. This will help the bank avoid failure and reduce the likelihood that taxpayers will have to step in to bail it out.
4. Yield and Risk
Because CoCo Bonds are riskier than a normal bond, the yield on CoCo Bonds is higher than that of a normal bond. Investors are compensated for the risk of a bond turning into shares or simply losing money. In calm economic climates, they will earn a good return; however, in times of economic crisis, they could incur losses.
Benefits and Risks Associated with CoCo Bonds
Just like other investments, CoCo Bonds have both benefits and risks. Let’s look at both sides.
Benefits of CoCo Bonds:
1. Higher Yields
CoCo Bonds usually pay higher interest rates than traditional bonds. This makes them attractive to investors seeking higher income, especially when interest rates are low.
2. Capital Support for Banks
For banks, CoCo Bonds are very helpful. They allow banks to raise money and strengthen their financial position during difficult times. This helps them stay solvent and continue operating without needing a government bailout.
3. Regulatory Compliance
Under Basel III rules, banks must maintain a certain level of capital to remain safe. CoCo Bonds help banks easily meet these rules. This makes them more secure and helps prevent another global banking crisis.
4. Flexibility
CoCo Bonds give banks more flexibility. They can convert debt into equity automatically in times of trouble, without having to ask investors or wait for government help. This quick response helps keep confidence in the banking system.
Risks of CoCo Bonds:
1. Uncertainty for Investors
The biggest risk of CoCo Bonds is uncertainty. If a trigger event occurs, the bond can turn into shares. This means investors might suddenly own part of the bank instead of getting their regular interest payments. If the bank’s shares are falling, this can lead to losses.
2. Trigger Events Are Beyond Investor Control
Investors cannot control when a trigger event happens. It depends on the bank’s financial condition and regulatory rules. If the bank performs poorly, the bonds may convert into shares unexpectedly, reducing their value.
3. Possible Loss of Capital
In some situations, CoCo Bonds may be fully written down, meaning investors may lose all their invested capital. If the bank is very weak or close to failing, it will be written down. This makes CoCo Bonds much riskier than any standard governmental or corporate debt.
4. Market Liquidity
CoCo Bonds may also be less liquid than other securities. This means investors may not be able to sell quickly if they need to exit their investment, especially in a panic during a market sell-off. If a crisis does occur, the market value of these bonds could decline sharply.
Additional Read: What Are Corporate Bonds?
Examples of Contingent Convertible Bonds
Example 1: European Bank CoCo Bonds
A large European bank issues CoCo Bonds with a face value of €1,000 each and a yearly interest rate of 6%. The bonds will convert into shares if the bank’s Tier 1 capital ratio falls below 7%.
If that happens, the €1,000 bond converts into shares at €10 per share. So, the investor receives 100 shares. This means that instead of getting the €1,000 back at maturity, the investor now owns shares in the bank, which could rise or fall in value depending on the market.
Example 2: Indian CoCo Bonds
A bank in India has issued CoCo Bonds with a conversion trigger of 8% for its capital adequacy ratio. If the bank's capital falls below 8%, the bonds automatically convert into shares. CoCo Bonds have a high interest rate of 8% and are appealing to potential investors.
Nonetheless, if the bank were to face economic problems, the investors might receive shares that are worth less than what they initially invested. Therefore, while returns are high, the risk is also high.
Conclusion
Contingent convertible bonds (CoCo bonds) are a specific category of financing instruments intended to provide banks and other financial institutions with strength in times of stress. They were created to enhance safety in the banking system while mitigating the need for government bailouts.
For banks, CoCo bonds offer an efficient and cost-effective way to raise capital in line with regulatory requirements. For investors, CoCo bonds offer above-average returns but come with additional risk. In the event of a capital deterioration of the bank itself, the bonds may convert into equity securities, or they could even be lost in the event of a complete loss of the bank's value.
CoCo bonds illustrate a modern-day attempt to find a compromise between safety and profit. They allow protection to the financial system from collapse, but investors must know the financial mechanisms of the CoCo bonds before purchasing the instrument.